How to Make Savory-Sweet Shallot Jam With 3 Ingredients

Hootinanny 0

A Big Little Recipe has the smallest-possible ingredient list and big everything else: flavor, creativity, wow factor. That means five ingredients or fewer—not including water, salt, black pepper, and certain fats (like oil and butter), since we’re guessing you have those covered. This week, we’re making a savory jam to smear on everything.


On a good day, jam refers to “a food made by boiling fruit and sugar to a thick consistency.” Or on a bad one, “a crowded mass that impedes or blocks movement.” This three-ingredient jam is neither.

Yes, we will be boiling. Yes, there will be sugar. But fruit? Not a strawberry or peach or even tomato in sight. Instead: shallots. Lots and lots of shallots.

Sure, jam is best known as a way to stretch summer’s bounty, to make fragile berries that would’ve gone moldy in days last for weeks or months. But just as jam need not be limited to fruits—hi bacon, hello red peppers—it need not be limited to warm weather either.

Come colder, clouder, gustier months, there are plenty of ingredients that would love to be stirred with sugar and simmered, simmered, simmered into oblivion. Especially alliums. Maybe you’ve already heard of onion jam, on ricotta-dolloped biscuit bites or goat cheese crostini. I like to think of shallot jam as the ultimate onion jam—what an onion dreams of becoming after it falls asleep.

“Shallots are one of the things—a basic prep item in every mise-en-place—that make restaurant food taste different from your food,” Anthony Bourdain wrote in Kitchen Confidential. “You should always have some around for sauces, dressings, and sauté items.”

Photo by Ty Mecham. Prop Stylist: Amanda Widis. Food Stylist: Samantha Seneviratne.

And jam. Score a couple pounds and you’re halfway to this high-impact spread that your fridge will be thrilled (chuffed!) to have around. Here’s the cheat sheet: Dice shallots and sauté until transparent-ish, like stained glass. Treat to sugar, which will encourage deeper, darker caramelization. Then wake things up with a hefty pour of vinegar.

The last ingredient depends on you—or, more specifically, what you already have around. My vote is for malt vinegar, widely known as the finishing touch on fish-and-chips, but it’s a wonder-ingredient in countless other places, too. In this case, it gives shallot jam a roasty, toasty—and, yeah, malty—flavor. Feel free to swap in other vinegars like white wine, red wine, rice, or any of those mixed with balsamic or black.

Once you have shallot jam around, the world is yours, as far as your eyes can see. Try it with:

  • Buttered toast
  • Triscuits and Gouda
  • Pork chops with sautéed peppers
  • Crispy sausage and scrambled eggs
  • Chopped liver (or liver mousse) toasts
  • Penne with butter and Parmesan
  • Roast chicken and any vegetables
  • Oil and vinegar as a vinaigrette
  • Rice-and-beans burrito
  • Fettuccine with Greek yogurt
  • Quesadilla or grilled cheese

I won’t try to hide it—the last one is my favorite. On a bad day, I’ll sandwich seedy bread, sharp cheddar, and shallot jam, griddle it until crispy outside, melty inside, then take a bite while it’s still too hot. Just like that, the bad day becomes a little better.

From Our Shop

Five Two Essential Sauté Pan

our line!

Five Two Essential Sauté Pan $119

Five Two Wooden Spoons

our line!

Five Two Wooden Spoons $25$99

More Styles

Five Two Essential Kitchen Towels

our line!

Five Two Essential Kitchen Towels $35$95

More Options

How will you use shallot jam? Let us know in the comments!

Find out More

Tags:

If you tried this recipe please let us all know how it was.